Creative Strategies of Idle Arcady RPGs

Butcher Hero and XP Hero are showing a new direction for Idle Arcade games: turning simple progression loops into RPG experiences.

While both games take clear inspiration from the formula popularized by Alien Invasion, their creative strategies are quite different.

I used Ad Insights by GameAnalytics to look through their creatives and see how each game approaches bringing in new users.

Alien Invasion by CrazyLabs
As one of the earliest games to popularize this hybrid casual formula, its creatives lean more heavily into hypercasual-style hooks, with much of the focus staying on the core gameplay itself. Looking through its older creatives, black-and-white variations also appear quite frequently, giving the same gameplay a different visual treatment.

Butcher Hero by Multicast Games
Here, the creatives tend to sell the game’s fantasy itself. Most ads introduce the origin of the protagonist, Butcher Hero, using narration-driven cinematic hooks before moving into the gameplay. From there, the focus shifts to the most satisfying parts of the progression loop: upgrades, mastery, increasingly intense battles, fast progression, and challenges.

When it comes to ad formats, video ads account for around 44% of estimated impressions, with playable ads accounting for another ~41%. And Mintegral is currently leading their ad network mix, followed by AppLovin.

XP Hero by Supercent
This game takes a different route by borrowing proven concepts from other genres. These creatives include ideas inspired by idle games, tower defense, and especially 4X titles like Kingshot, Whiteout Survival, and Top Heroes. The use of 4X creatives here is interesting, as those games have themselves experimented heavily with mechanics and hooks borrowed from other genres. They also emphasize the “No Ads” angle in their creatives, while the game itself contains quite a lot of ads.

For XP Hero, AppLovin is the leading ad network, while Mintegral follows closely. And around 37% of estimated impressions come from video ads, while the majority, ~55%, comes through playable ads.

Three games built around relatively similar core loops, but three very different ways of selling it.

And these probably won’t be the only approaches we see in the future, as more games are already entering the market following a similar blueprint.

This post is sponsored by GameAnalytics.